Brian Gavin Diamonds Reviews 1,834

I met with Brian in person to review diamonds and I couldn’t be more impressed with his in house collection. They were extremely helpful throughout the entire process and crafted the ring exactly to m... See more

Process was very smooth from beginning to end. Employees was very helpful and kept me informed of any updates. Finished product is amazing.

Earrings in time for a birthday! I am very happy with the service from the Brian Gavin team. I ordered a pair of earrings only 1 week before my wife's birthday, and the team did a great job ensurin... See more

The one on one support with a human, Katie Homuth, as a posed to working through computer recordings. From conversation I was convinced of legitimacy of company and quality of the product. I have... See more

I could not have asked for better help than Emily provided. She quickly responded to my many questions and handled any concerns with warm, heartfelt responses. I was hesitant to make such a big purcha... See more

I received the absolute best customer service from Emily Johnson! Among many other things, she arranged for me to talk to Brian Gavin, who was also an interesting and very impressive person....and... See more

Always a great experience at Brian Gavin Diamonds. Katie always gives us great advice and is incredibly helpful. Honestly, when it comes to jewelry or diamond questions, Katie is always my first and... See more

I did a lot of research over the last 3 years before I purchased a 3-carat 3-prong diamond bracelet from Brian Gavin. I reseached multiple online vendors (White Flash, Brilliant Earth, James All... See more

Emily was great to work with and answered all my questions and concerns. Emily helped me decided between a variety of stones giving me her honest opinion by what she was able to see in person and not... See more

Everything about Brian Gavin Diamonds has literally been a 5 Star DIAMOND experience. There is no way I could have imagined how beautiful the ring I purchased would turn out! I know what I hoped for... See more

This was a great experience thanks to Katie! What a beautiful diamond ring. We had no idea how to go about purchasing a diamond ring so thanks to Katie’s professional, kind, expert help everything wen... See more

Brian and his team has done it again!! My 5 stone trellis ring turned out beautifully!! The diamonds and the setting are absolutely gorgeous. This was a long time in the making and I’m so thrilled to... See more

Best experience. And blown away by the craftsmanship. I knew it would be nice based on other reviews but it turned out even better than expected. I’d recommend working with Emily J if you can. She was... See more

As always we had an amazing experience with Brian Gavin Diamonds! I have a family diamond that was used for my wedding ring years ago. My husband originally came here to get it set in a beautiful band... See more

Brian Gavin Diamonds provided excellent service. The entire process, from start to finish, went very smoothly, with great communication. I'm very pleased with the experience and will definitely be... See more

Brian Gavin Diamonds is my go-to for high quality diamonds. They provided high quality super ideal stones for my engagement ring, wedding ring, and several upgrades, as well as spectacular oval and em... See more

Service is excellent, all queries are promptly answered. Craftsmenship of the ring and brilliance of the lab diamond surpasses expectations. The premium is well worth it, can't recommend it enough. A... See more

I felt safe buying from Brian Gavin. I did a lot of research and customers and reviewers from many sites recommended Brian Gavin. My bracelet is simply stunning. Every day when I glance at my wrist I... See more

Was looking to purchase a 5 year anniversary gift and reached back out to Brian Gavin as my wife loved her hearts and arrows diamond for her engagement/wedding ring. Shocked to work with the same repr... See more

This is the 3rd time I’ve purchase from BG. Am forever a customer. Honestly you just can’t beat the quality of their product, their reputation, and knowledge. Emily and Katie both made recommendation... See more

Very happy with the service I received. Shopping was blazing fast and the stone was beautiful!

Katie was super professional, helpful and patient throughout the process of buying my wife’s engagement ring and wedding band. Brian Gavin Diamonds went above and beyond to make sure it was made and d... See more

Great selection and impressive customer service! The stone we received was beautiful and top quality. You get what you pay for is true and I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend Brian Gavin! Also Leslie I w... See more

Emily helped me with upgrading the diamond in my engagement ring made by Brian Gavin Diamonds 15 years ago. She gave great advice in picking a new stone. Instead of setting the new diamond in the or... See more

We couldn't be happier! The engagement ring was just so beautiful!!! It made me teary eyed and smily :) Absolutely STUNNING!! The craftsmanship and diamond were impressive!!! The sparkle is just wow... See more

Most importantly, the ring (Juno with a 3kt premium lab diamond) came out beautifully. Sparkle is insane. Also, helpful customer service over the phone when ordering and when the ring was being shippe... See more

I am so pleased with my experience working with the Brian Gavin team! Emily was incredibly helpful in finding the perfect pair of diamond studs for an earring set. Her knowledge and impeccable Custome... See more

I had been specifically looking for a cushion hearts and arrows diamond and it is limited where they are sold. Came across Brian Gavin and I'm glad I did. Their representative that I was in contact wi... See more

Brian Gavin Diamonds and working with Emily was nothing short of exceptional. I am the type of person that takes 2 weeks of research to buy a cellphone case. Imagine how much time I spent reading up o... See more

Me and my fiancee both loved Brian Gavin's diamonds, sparkles more than any other that we had seen! Lesley and Emily were fantastic to work with and went above and beyond to the ring during a busy tim... See more

Katie Homuth and I have been exchanging emails since I began my inquiry for a pair of Quadrex Black diamonds in March 2025. In May, a pair that was compliant with BG standards was available and I proc... See more

I had the most wonderful experience working with Lesley and Katie to create our engagement ring. Even though I was abroad, they patiently walked me through every step, ensuring I felt confident and w... See more

Staff was very friendly with great communication and feedback. One area that could be better is the website for screening engagement rings, search perimeters were lacking.

Thank you for such stunning pieces! The customer service was phenomenal and the pieces are breath taking! Well above and beyond my expectations.

I was browsing the site when a few diamonds caught my eye. Worked with Katie who listened to my requirements and short listed a few diamonds for me to consider. We finally found THE one. She also guid... See more

Was recommended Brian Gavin by a friend - my experience couldn't be better. Had an issue with my order which was resolved excellently and timely. The diamond I ordered for my Fiancé arrived quickly,... See more

I cannot say enough good things about Brian Gavin Diamonds. This is the my 10th time purchasing from them. The workmanship is outstanding and the cut of the diamonds is better than I have ever... See more

Great company to do business with - very transparent and honest - highly recommend!

My husband and I recently purchased a Black by Brian Gavin diamond to be sent to a designer and set into a ring. We worked with Emily, who I understand has been there for quite some time. From the... See more